Home League Scoring Records
| Description | Record | Detail, dates link to results |
| Highest scoring win | 8 | Sutton United 8 Kettering Town 0, 14.10.1986 |
| Highest scoring loss | 6 | Sutton United 0 Grays Athletic 6, 29.01.2005 |
| Highest winning margin | 8 | Sutton United 8 Kettering Town 0, 14.10.1986 |
| Highest losing margin | 6 | Sutton United 0 Grays Athletic 6, 29.01.2005 |
| Highest aggregate | 9 | Sutton United 7 Bath City 2, 01.11.1986 |
| Highest scoring draw | 3 |
Sutton United 3 Enfield 3, 22.03.1988 Sutton United 3 Northwich Victoria 3, 25.02.1989 Sutton United 3 Barrow 3, 28.04.1990 Sutton United 3 Gateshead 3, 27.10.1990 Sutton United 3 Basingstoke Town 3, 19.08.2006 Sutton United 3 Tonbridge Angels 3, 11.11.2008 |
Away League Scoring Records
| Description | Record | Detail, dates link to results |
| Highest scoring win | 9 | Gateshead 0 Sutton United 9, 22.09.1990 |
| Highest scoring loss | 6 |
Barnet 6 Sutton United 2, 28.12.1987 Morecambe 6 Sutton United 2, 04.12.1999 Dover Athletic 6 Sutton United 0, 28.03.2009 Dartford 6 Sutton United 1, 20.03.2012 |
| Highest winning margin | 9 | Gateshead 0 Sutton United 9, 22.09.1990 |
| Highest losing margin | 6 | Dover Athletic 6 Sutton United 0, 28.03.2009 |
| Highest aggregate | 9 |
Gateshead 0 Sutton United 9, 22.09.1990 Dorchester Town 5 Sutton United 4, 18.11.2006 |
| Highest scoring draw | 3 |
Telford United 3 Sutton United 3, 29.08.1987 Hayes and Yeading U 3 Sutton United 3, 17.11.2007 |
Cup Scoring Records
| Description | Record | Detail, dates link to results |
| Highest scoring win | 4 |
Sutton United 4 Hillingdon Borough 1, 12.01.1970 Dagenham 0 Sutton United 4, 19.11.1988 Colchester United 3 Sutton United 4, 13.11.1993 |
| Highest scoring loss | 8 | Norwich City 8 Sutton United 0, 28.01.1989 |
| Highest winning margin | 4 | Dagenham 0 Sutton United 4, 19.11.1988 |
| Highest losing margin | 8 | Norwich City 8 Sutton United 0, 28.01.1989 |
| Highest aggregate | 9 | Walthamstow Avenue 7 Sutton United 2, 24.11.1945 |
| Highest scoring draw | 2 |
Sutton United 2 Romford (old 2) 2, 05.11.1960 Bishop's Stortford 2 Sutton United 2, 21.11.1981 Kidderminster Harr 2 Sutton United 2, 11.11.1995 |
Full League Sequences
| Description | Record | Detail, dates link to results |
| Wins | 8 | 01.04.2013 to 27.04.2013 |
| Draws | 4 | 02.03.1991 to 23.03.1991 |
| Losses | 9 | 08.09.2007 to 10.11.2007 |
| Clean sheets | 5 | 21.08.2010 to 04.09.2010 |
| Failing to score | 5 |
22.04.2000 to 03.05.2000 08.03.2006 to 01.04.2006 |
| w/o a Win | 15 | 08.09.2007 to 29.12.2007 |
| w/o a Draw | 21 | 02.04.2005 to 12.11.2005 |
| w/o a Loss | 14 | 23.01.2010 to 27.03.2010 |
| w/o a Clean sheet | 21 | 27.10.1990 to 26.03.1991 |
| w/o Failing to score | 17 | 06.10.1986 to 14.02.1987 |
Home League Sequences
| Description | Record | Detail, dates link to results |
| Wins | 10 | 25.01.2011 to 25.04.2011 |
| Draws | 4 |
03.01.2000 to 06.04.2000 14.02.2009 to 21.03.2009 |
| Losses | 7 | 27.08.2007 to 22.12.2007 |
| Clean sheets | 3 |
16.09.1986 to 04.10.1986 07.04.1990 to 16.04.1990 28.03.2005 to 23.04.2005 10.09.2005 to 18.10.2005 24.08.2010 to 04.09.2010 |
| Failing to score | 3 |
22.04.2000 to 03.05.2000 24.03.2007 to 07.04.2007 05.09.2009 to 31.10.2009 |
| w/o a Win | 11 | 20.04.2000 to 23.10.2004 |
| w/o a Draw | 18 | 05.09.1989 to 16.04.1990 |
| w/o a Loss | 22 | 24.04.2010 to 25.04.2011 |
| w/o a Clean sheet | 11 | 18.08.2007 to 26.01.2008 |
| w/o Failing to score | 27 | 20.10.1987 to 11.02.1989 |
Away League Sequences
| Description | Record | Detail, dates link to results |
| Wins | 4 |
11.12.2004 to 22.01.2005 30.04.2005 to 29.08.2005 |
| Draws | 4 | 17.11.2007 to 29.12.2007 |
| Losses | 7 |
26.03.1991 to 21.08.1999 27.12.1999 to 18.03.2000 |
| Clean sheets | 4 | 30.04.2005 to 29.08.2005 |
| Failing to score | 4 |
26.12.2005 to 17.01.2006 25.02.2006 to 01.04.2006 22.08.2006 to 16.09.2006 |
| w/o a Win | 16 |
26.03.1988 to 31.12.1988 17.09.2005 to 04.04.2006 |
| w/o a Draw | 22 | 08.03.2006 to 17.03.2007 |
| w/o a Loss | 11 | 18.04.1987 to 28.10.1987 |
| w/o a Clean sheet | 43 | 29.09.1990 to 11.09.2004 |
| w/o Failing to score | 11 |
30.10.2004 to 02.04.2005 06.02.2010 to 20.04.2010 |
