Scoring Records
| Description | Record | Detail, dates link to results |
| Highest home score | 13 | Bermuda 13 Montserrat 0, 29.02.2004 |
| Highest away score | 8 | US Virgin Islands 1 Antigua and Barbuda 8, 06.09.2011 |
| Highest neutral score | 10 | Dominica 0 Mexico 10 (n), 19.06.2004 |
| Highest home margin | 13 | Bermuda 13 Montserrat 0, 29.02.2004 |
| Highest away margin | 7 |
St Vincent and Gren 0 Honduras 7, 14.11.2000 Montserrat 0 Bermuda 7, 21.03.2004 US Virgin Islands 1 Antigua and Barbuda 8, 06.09.2011 St Lucia 0 Canada 7, 07.10.2011 US Virgin Islands 0 Haiti 7, 07.10.2011 |
| Highest neutral margin | 10 | Dominica 0 Mexico 10 (n), 19.06.2004 |
| Highest aggregate | 14 | Honduras 11 St Vincent and Gren 3, 17.11.1996 |
| Highest scoring draw | 4 | Guatemala 4 Costa Rica 4, 28.08.1960 |
